Utah Tells Sentinel Security Life to Stop Writing New Business

News December 05, 2024 at 02:34 PM
Share & Print

/contrib/content/uploads/sites/415/2024/01/2022-3-3-money_iStock_640x640.jpg

The owner of a fixed annuity issuer is clashing with Utah insurance regulators over how the regulators are valuing its investment portfolio.

The Utah department has issued an emergency order telling the company, Sentinel Security Life Insurance Company, to stop selling new products by Dec. 31.

Regulators also ordered two Sentinel Security Life reinsurance affiliates, Haymarket Insurance and Jazz Reinsurance, to stop writing new business.

The companies are owned by Advantage Capital Partners, a company also known as A-CAP.

The Utah order does not affect renewal policies, and it does not affect another annuity issuer owned by Advantage Capital, Atlantic Coast Life.

Utah regulators are acting because Harvest Investments, a valuation specialist used by an examination firm the regulators hired, believes that the Sentinel Security Life group's asset total includes too much value related to three loans. The loans were made to companies involved with aviation and aviation leasing. Harvest Investors found that the three loans are non-performing and have a low expected recovery value. Using what Harvest Investors believes to be the loans' true current market value leads to the Sentinel Security Life group having $522 million in negative capital and surplus, according to the emergency order.

Advantage Capital said through a representative that it disagrees with Utah regulators' assessment of the loans and of the Sentinel Security Life group's finances.

"A-CAP vigorously disputes the flawed valuation conducted by an unqualified firm," the representative said. "A-CAP stands by its valuation work, which was validated by two highly qualified and independent valuation firms, and is challenging the order to protect its policyholders, its investors, and the interests of the broader aviation leasing industry participants."

The backdrop: Sentinel Security Life started in 1948 as a policyholder-owned mutual company, according to Utah Insurance Department examination reports. The company converted to a capital stock company in 1954.

Advantage Capital bought the company in 2016.

Sentinel Security Life's financial statements show that the company reported $36 million in net income for the first half of the year on $294 million in revenue and $1.9 billion in assets. Most of the revenue came from sales of annuities.

Sentinel Security Life recorded $453 million in new annuity sales in the third quarter, and Atlantic Coast Life recorded $263 million in new annuity sales, according to issuer survey data from Wink Inc.

Credit: iStock

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center